Windy Community

    • Register
    • Login
    • Search
    • Unread
    • Categories
    • Groups
    • Go to windy.com

    GFS (NOAA) Forecast Inaccuracies

    Your Feedback and Suggestions
    3
    8
    179
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • needsomecoffee
      needsomecoffee last edited by

      The last few weeks, the GFS (NOAA) forecast has not appeared accurate for my location (48.29/-122.64?48.082). The high temps are always about 10 degrees below all the other forecasts when displayed in "compare" mode (image 1 below). The GFS temps are also lower than the temps NOAA shows on its own hourly forecast page for the same location (image 2 below). Again, this forecast inconsistency has appeared only in the last few weeks. Prior to this GFS was much more consistent with the other forecasts and the NOAA page.
      Screen Shot 2022-08-09 at 7.51.38 AM.png
      Screen Shot 2022-08-09 at 7.52.15 AM.png

      Korina 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • Korina
        Korina Administrator @needsomecoffee last edited by

        @needsomecoffee Hello, I suggest trying other models available for your area to compare their results.

        Korina

        needsomecoffee 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
        • needsomecoffee
          needsomecoffee @Korina last edited by

          @korina I am using Windy's 5-forecast compare, so I am using different models. Just now I have only 4 to compare as the GFS data Windy is getting from NOAA's data appears to be wrong. Not a big deal, but it was not a problem previously. Something appears to be in error re: how Windy is pulling/using the NOAA data. NOAA data, as per my second post, is pretty easy to review on NOAA's site. The data pretty clearly shows Windy's error. Thanks for the reply.

          idefix37 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • idefix37
            idefix37 Sailor Moderator @needsomecoffee last edited by idefix37

            @needsomecoffee
            The discrepancy that you have noticed is not observed everywhere. Here in Western Europe GFS is matching quite well to other models even if it is generally 3°C above the others for the max temp.

            39383F9F-4A28-4992-AC5C-5F056E9AB11B.jpeg

            So, it would be useful that you give your approx. location.

            needsomecoffee 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • needsomecoffee
              needsomecoffee @idefix37 last edited by

              @idefix37
              I put the lat/long coordinates for my location (North Whidbey Island, WA) in my original post: 48.29/-122.64.

              I just checked the daily high temps for GFS (NOAA) number from Windy 5-fcst compare vs. the NOAA forecast for the same location.
              Fri Aug 12: Compare -5F lower
              Sat Aug 13: Compare -5F lower
              Sun Aug 14: Compare -8F lower

              I have seen some other posts where this inconsistency is being noted. It may not be at all locations.

              Hope it gets fixed, but this thread does not suggest Windy engineering will investigate. Unless they are grabbing the NOAA number from a non-NOAA site, this does not make sense.

              Not too big a loss as GFS is less accurate overall vs. the other 4 models which I tend to rely on more.

              Thx.

              idefix37 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
              • idefix37
                idefix37 Sailor Moderator @needsomecoffee last edited by idefix37

                @needsomecoffee
                I have not found a GFS prediction for this island on a NOAA website. On 2 other weather apps the discrepancy of GFS and other models is approximately the same as that seen on Windy. This is confirms by the Observation vs forecast tool in Windy.

                How can we explain this discrepancy? GFS has the lowest resolution of all model used in Windy. The GFS grid has a 22km spacing which means that if a point is on the island, the others are probably offshore. The maximum temperature over the waters is much lower than over the land. Then between grid points the temperature is interpolated and smoothed. So with GFS you cannot get a precise maximum temperature in this island.

                08C7CE78-BAE3-45CE-A416-EA39D2CC1214.jpeg

                You can see the effect of model resolution by comparing GFS 22 km and HRRR 4km

                GFS 22 km
                C6A5BD3D-ED52-4F7F-A5BF-69B79FE11BEF.jpeg

                HRRR 4km
                BA872E00-97B8-4A3F-B417-4C16307BE845.jpeg

                Due to higher resolution HRRR shows definitely a better contrast between sea and land than GFS.

                needsomecoffee 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                • needsomecoffee
                  needsomecoffee @idefix37 last edited by

                  @idefix37
                  As I noted, the GFS/NOAA model in my 5-model comparison is the least accurate so I use it the least. Also, I have the NOAA hourly forecast bookmarked, so it is just one click to get the the "real" NOAA forecast.

                  Cliff Mass (University of Washington Professor) has a blog where he has described why NOAA's models are less accurate (standard USA stupid stuff).

                  The weird Windy !== NOAA numbers problem exists for my location. So now my "Compare" is between 4 models not 5 unless this gets fixed. (Again, this problem appeared recently. It did not exist previously.)

                  idefix37 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                  • idefix37
                    idefix37 Sailor Moderator @needsomecoffee last edited by idefix37

                    @needsomecoffee said in GFS (NOAA) Forecast Inaccuracies:

                    unless this gets fixed. (Again, this problem appeared recently. It did not exist previously.)

                    Windy will not fix the GFS temperature issue on this island. Windy cannot change the GFS resolution.
                    To be more clear, here are the 4 points of GFS grid as shown by https://spotwx.com/ . One is on the island, the 3 others are over the sea. Interpolating (averaging) the temperatures of these 4 points cannot give a good temperature over the land of the island in the hotter hours in summer.

                    713A36B9-D423-4E3A-B14F-6EA68581BDE7.jpeg

                    64719189-B615-4BB9-AED7-E8801A87DE67.jpeg

                    BTW HRRR is more precise because the 4 points are on the land.

                    Why does the NOAA give a good temperature with GFS?
                    Probably because they use the nearest point of the 4, in this case that on the land. They do not average the 4 temperatures.

                    Why can’t Windy do the same instead of averaging the 4 temperatures?
                    Because this is the only way to draw a temperature map. The ‘nearest point’ can only be used for a point forecast.

                    Why some months ago, GFS was providing correct temperatures in Windy?
                    Probably because at that time of the year, the temperature over the land and that over the sea were not so different as they are in summer.

                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                    • Referenced by  idefix37 idefix37 
                    • First post
                      Last post
                    Windyty, S.E. - all rights reserved. Powered by excellent NodeBB
                    NodeBB & contributors, OSM & contributors, HERE maps
                    Terms of Use     Privacy Policy