Windy Community
    • Unread
    • Categories
    • Groups
    • Go to windy.com
    • Register
    • Login

    GFS temperature VS Weatheronline

    Bug Reports
    2
    15
    2.2k
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • idefix37I
      idefix37 Sailor Moderator @zhaoy
      last edited by

      @zhaoy
      Could you show your code.

      Z 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • Z
        zhaoy @idefix37 | Premium
        last edited by zhaoy

        @idefix37 I picked up steps with numerical values on color legend, and other steps were interpolated by numerical values
        [[245,[136,136,136,255]],[246.5,[176,176,176,255]],[248,[204,204,204,255]],[249.5,[228,228,228,255]],[251,[119,51,119,255]],[253.4,[170,51,170,255]],[255.8,[204,51,204,255]],[258.2,[255,51,255,255]],[260.6,[255,153,255,255]],[263,[21,0,204,255]],[265,[51,102,255,255]],[267,[51,153,255,255]],[269,[51,204,255,255]],[271,[51,255,255,255]],[273,[0,119,0,255]],[275.4,[0,153,0,255]],[277.8,[0,187,0,255]],[280.2,[0,221,0,255]],[282.6,[0,255,0,255]],[285,[255,255,51,255]],[286.75,[255,238,51,255]],[288.5,[255,221,51,255]],[290.25,[255,204,51,255]],[292,[255,187,51,255]],[293.75,[255,170,0,255]],[295.5,[255,153,0,255]],[297.25,[255,119,0,255]],[299,[255,0,0,255]],[301,[238,0,0,255]],[303,[204,0,0,255]],[305,[187,0,0,255]],[307,[170,0,0,255]],[309,[153,0,0,255]],[311,[136,0,0,255]],[313.5,[114,0,0,255]],[316,[91,0,0,255]],[318.5,[66,0,0,255]],[321,[29,0,0,255]]]

        idefix37I 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
        • idefix37I
          idefix37 Sailor Moderator @zhaoy
          last edited by idefix37

          @zhaoy
          Thank you.
          Could you try

          [[245,[136,136,136,255]],[247.9,[176,176,176,255]],[248,[204,204,204,255]],[250.9,[228,228,228,255]], [251,[119,51,119,255]], …etc

          It should improve the scale, but not sure you get exactly what you want.

          Z 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • Z
            zhaoy @idefix37 | Premium
            last edited by

            @idefix37 thank you! the result is not yet which I wanted,I think the same data source (GFS 0.25°) should render the same results,but the Weatheronline image has many small patches,and the boundary is quite sharp.
            WeatherOnline Result:
            b72829d3-5ee7-4021-9530-460ec2eabf15-image.png

            so,I guess Windy did some smoothing on the data, I don't know if it's appropriate.
            such as this picture
            4ee3e094-1cd8-46ce-9f5d-f21d881d3be8-image.png

            idefix37I 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • idefix37I
              idefix37 Sailor Moderator @zhaoy
              last edited by idefix37

              @zhaoy
              You are being picky. I find the granularity to be pretty good.
              At boundary between the value ranges the limit is jagged. Can you try taking a screenshot of the Icing layer of the same device.
              Then could you explain the 2 squares with numbers. How did you make them ?

              Z 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • Z
                zhaoy | Premium
                last edited by zhaoy

                The temperature data(GFS 0.5°) render result on meteoblue,which also has many small patches,and the boundary is quite
                https://www.meteoblue.com/en/weather/maps/#coords=5.65/37.766/99.822&map=temperature~hourly~GFS05~2 m above gnd~none

                81ea7421-afcc-4397-b2d3-90c1d660f96a-image.png

                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                • Z
                  zhaoy @idefix37 | Premium
                  last edited by

                  @idefix37 I'm just guessing if Windy smoothed the source data to make it look better

                  idefix37I 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                  • idefix37I
                    idefix37 Sailor Moderator @zhaoy
                    last edited by idefix37

                    @zhaoy
                    I didn't realize you didn't apply the correct coding.

                    0309D9EB-32EC-4880-A2C3-C31569678643.jpeg

                    As already said, your coding should be like this theoretical diagram

                    97BA89E3-6C5F-4AD8-8D53-12FE10EC7482.jpeg

                    Z 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                    • Z
                      zhaoy @idefix37 | Premium
                      last edited by

                      @idefix37 I guess it's not a color rendering issue, Did Windy lose a lot of details in smoothing the source data(GFS 0.25°)

                      [[245,[136,136,136,255]],[246.4,[136,136,136,255]],[246.5,[176,176,176,255]],[247.9,[176,176,176,255]],[248,[204,204,204,255]],[249.4,[204,204,204,255]],[249.5,[228,228,228,255]],[250.9,[228,228,228,255]],[251,[119,51,119,255]],[253.3,[119,51,119,255]],[253.4,[170,51,170,255]],[255.7,[170,51,170,255]],[255.8,[204,51,204,255]],[258.1,[204,51,204,255]],[258.2,[255,51,255,255]],[260.5,[255,51,255,255]],[260.6,[255,153,255,255]],[262.9,[255,153,255,255]],[263,[21,0,204,255]],[264.9,[21,0,204,255]],[265,[51,102,255,255]],[266.9,[51,102,255,255]],[267,[51,153,255,255]],[268.9,[51,153,255,255]],[269,[51,204,255,255]],[270.9,[51,204,255,255]],[271,[51,255,255,255]],[272.9,[51,255,255,255]],[273,[0,119,0,255]],[275.3,[0,119,0,255]],[275.4,[0,153,0,255]],[277.7,[0,153,0,255]],[277.8,[0,187,0,255]],[280.1,[0,187,0,255]],[280.2,[0,221,0,255]],[282.5,[0,221,0,255]],[282.6,[0,255,0,255]],[284.9,[0,255,0,255]],[285,[255,255,51,255]],[286.65,[255,255,51,255]],[286.75,[255,238,51,255]],[288.4,[255,238,51,255]],[288.5,[255,221,51,255]],[290.15,[255,221,51,255]],[290.25,[255,204,51,255]],[291.9,[255,204,51,255]],[292,[255,187,51,255]],[293.65,[255,187,51,255]],[293.75,[255,170,0,255]],[295.4,[255,170,0,255]],[295.5,[255,153,0,255]],[297.15,[255,153,0,255]],[297.25,[255,119,0,255]],[298.9,[255,119,0,255]],[299,[255,0,0,255]],[300.9,[255,0,0,255]],[301,[238,0,0,255]],[302.9,[238,0,0,255]],[303,[204,0,0,255]],[304.9,[204,0,0,255]],[305,[187,0,0,255]],[306.9,[187,0,0,255]],[307,[170,0,0,255]],[308.9,[170,0,0,255]],[309,[153,0,0,255]],[310.9,[153,0,0,255]],[311,[136,0,0,255]],[313.4,[136,0,0,255]],[313.5,[114,0,0,255]],[315.9,[114,0,0,255]],[316,[91,0,0,255]],[318.4,[91,0,0,255]],[318.5,[66,0,0,255]],[320.9,[66,0,0,255]],[321,[29,0,0,255]]]

                      Windy (GFS 0.25°):
                      cd7deff2-9664-424a-acd1-9caa5ff2d2fc-image.png

                      Meteoblue (GFS 0.5°):
                      9f875cfe-b173-4213-b8df-f234db48a6e6-image.png

                      WeatherOnline (GFS 0.25°):
                      1bf39bd8-cb58-47dd-b151-abbd5c25f554-image.png

                      idefix37I 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                      • idefix37I
                        idefix37 Sailor Moderator @zhaoy
                        last edited by

                        @zhaoy
                        You already posted the same screenshots.
                        You can guess what you want.
                        End

                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                        • First post
                          Last post
                        Windyty, S.E. - all rights reserved. Powered by excellent NodeBB
                        NodeBB & contributors, OSM & contributors, HERE maps
                        Terms of Use     Privacy Policy