Meteoblue AI - a (smart) merge of all models does not give the best results
-
@Nwatchweather hello, after recording my forecasting options the wind map options are correct as well as the gust wind map one. The 1 hour option is steady if I don't quit windy but the next time I launch it it goes back to 3-hours display.
Note I didn't test every maps but the ones I need are in the same state before the update relative to Mblue AI -
I agree with Daniel Barbieri. I use windy for bay sailing in Florida and the Metoblue AI presents misleading results at best (2-3 mph every day at all times of day, essentially no data) . My preferred is HRRR or ECWF. Please remove the default to Meteoblue AI.
-
@Jean-Orr
As Premium user you can set your preferred model as default.
In the mobile app
In the browser version

-
Long time (but not premium) user here. I'd like to join the choir to make ECMWF the default model on the Basic forecast. Meteoblue is probably the less accurate for my state, so I have to manually switch every time. Please consider it.
Thanks.
Marco -
D David Polášek marked this topic as a question on
-
D David Polášek has marked this topic as solved on
-
Joining chorus. It’s complete rubbish for US Virgin Islands. I don’t think I’ve ever seen it over 10 knots even when it is blowing 20. I look at my spots and all are white with no wind when I can look outside and see white caps. And you can’t change it for your locations no matter what default you select. You can just compare it to other models they are all orange and red on windy days and blue model is white and blue. Why push a model that Meteoblue even explicitly acknowledges that its wind speed forecasts are significantly less accurate on islands and in close proximity to oceans. I already cancelled but had paid annually. Windy’s response when I complained was cookie cutter. Not much point in windy when it can’t even forecast windy.
-
@Brett-Ellis-2 Regarding to this topic, I can confirm that we will do more changes and adjustments in our next update planned for October. Meteoblue will be completely a default there, however, if you change the default model as a Premium user, it will be respected over the whole app.
We are aware of this unfortunate step between now, but we will do our best to improve this.
-
I agree with your observations, which I also had the opportunity to verify while sailing along the coasts of Western Europe.
its wind speed forecasts are significantly less accurate on islands and in close proximity to oceans.
Wind forecasts at sea near the coast by Meteoblue almost always underestimate actual wind speeds.
I reported it to Meteoblue and a team member explained that near the coast their multimodel system was only selecting the grid points from these models over the land, which provide of course a lower wind forecast than over the sea. This is better for people living there because wind speed and temperature forecasts are defined over the land.
I then suggested that, for a position at sea, they should use only marine grid points. However, the response I received was unclear.Meteoblue even explicitly acknowledges that its wind speed forecasts are significantly less accurate on islands and in close proximity to oceans.
Please could you provide a link to this information ?
I already cancelled but had paid annually. Windy’s response when I complained was cookie cutter. Not much point in windy when it can’t even forecast windy.
I don’t think this is a good idea, because as @suty said, Premium users will have the possibility to choose the default model they want in the detailed forecast tables.
For now, as a Premium user, you can do this as explained in my message above.And you can’t change it for your locations no matter what default you select.
Have you really set a default model, or are you talking about the “5-days forecast” for you Favorites?
-
@marcorotta They are making windy less usable for unpaid user for several years for now, also disturbing Premium users with extra switches and doubtful UI inventions on this way. I wish your voice would be heard, but there is not much hope there.
-
@idefix37 Hi, unfortunately this does not work - model (IOS App) still defaults to mblueAI on every restart of the App aven when I set it to ECMWF. This is very annoying a I really do not like mblue AI to be my default model.
-
model (IOS App) still defaults to mblueAI on every restart of the App
Not for me with iOS app. It has remained on the ECMWF model for several weeks.
What detailed forecast table are you using? Basic, Meteogram, Wind, Compare…? -
@idefix37 I am using mostly Basic and it keeps reverting to mblue AI.
-
@Voda-0 You need also to turn the switch on, I mean the one next to "Always open as Basic", do you have this turned on?
